2026-07-04T17:54:45.102Z

Always faithful! Been coming here since High School. Whenever passing through I love stopping in. Pizza is second to none plus the delicious ranch dressing.

2026-07-04T07:11:22.782Z

I placed a pick up order for three pizzas, all large sized because they had a summer special which was a one large 2-topping pizza for $19.99. I went with one pepperoni, one mushroom and pepperoni, and one jalapeño and pepperoni. The three large was big enough to feed 7 people. The pizza was absolutely delicious. The young man working the front counter was very nice and threw in 7 ranch for free. I can’t rate the atmosphere because I only walked in to pick up the pizza but it was very busy. I’ll definitely be back soon to eat there instead of take out. I think it’s some of the best pizza I’ve had around here.

2026-07-04T04:52:54.808Z

Their pizza is feel-good pizza. High quality ingredients, flaky crust, thick sausage and flavorful sauce. Great beer selection too! Came here tonight with my out-of-state guests and we all so pleased with the meal! Enjoyed watching the World Cup and the air hockey table. Thank you New York Pizzeria, you never disappoint

2026-07-04T03:09:08.462Z

Love the pizza and the owners are so nice! Highly recommend 😊

2026-07-03T00:52:40.379Z

Delicious pizza and wings! Consistent flavor each time we visit!

2026-07-01T22:00:32.808Z

Robbie and the staff are so friendly and kind. I love the atmosphere and the pizza and bourbon wings are delicious

2026-06-24T16:32:48.455Z

A fun atmosphere.

2026-06-19T04:30:43.361Z