2026-10-09T19:40:01.666Z

We had an absolutely wonderful stay at J&S Reeve Cottages! The property is beautiful, charming, and so thoughtfully cared for. It’s clear that the owners truly love their property, and that love shines through in every detail. Everything feels welcoming, peaceful, and well maintained, making it the perfect place to relax and unwind. Their pride in what they do and the care they put into creating a special experience for their guests really set this place apart. We couldn’t have asked for a better stay and would wholeheartedly recommend J&S Reeve Cottages to anyone looking for a lovely getaway. We would absolutely love to return!

2026-09-08T16:24:52.206Z

Wonderful place to stay and truly great hosts! The space was clean, open, bright, and airy—offering a perfect "east end chic" vibe. Excellent amenities throughout. I recommend this property without hesitation!

2026-08-03T00:00:00.000Z

What a wonderful place! The cottages are so beautiful, and the grounds are absolutely immaculate. John and Sandra are incredible hosts so attentive and thoughtful. They have everything, both inside and out, in flawless condition. We truly enjoyed our stay and would highly recommend it!

2026-07-24T13:15:36.000Z

Staying at cottage #1 can be summed up in two words: Pure Bliss...the grounds are absolutely stunning...I felt transported back to a time when life was much simpler...Sandy and John felt like old friends....easy access to kayaks and paddle boards on the grounds...amazing beaches and wineries close by....this in NOT a "Hamptons" vacation....this is a place to regroup and connect with family...We had our own little oasis...screened in porch which became our "spot"....grilling with charcoal brought back a smell that reminded me of my childhood...pet friendly( We've never seen our dog so relaxed)and zero traffic to deal with...."On The Dock" restaurant/ marina provided us with a quick place to grab a bite with food that far exceeded our expectations! and the sunflower fields and farmsteads!!! Highly recommend!

2026-07-18T02:40:12.881Z

We had a great stay at J&S Cottages and would definitely recommend it to anyone visiting the Southold area. The cottage was clean, comfortable, and had everything we needed. The location was perfect—quiet and relaxing, but still close to the wineries, restaurants, shops, and everything else the North Fork has to offer. The property is absolutely beautiful, they have plenty of things to do on the water that’s right outside the cottages. The owners Sandy & John were welcoming, responsive, and made the entire stay easy from start to finish. It was the perfect place for a relaxing getaway, and we would absolutely stay here again.