2026-08-27T15:40:12.043Z

Me encanta la comida en este lugar. El servicio es buenísimo. Y el ambiente muy agradable.

2026-08-11T01:54:44.642Z

Our sunday dinner was good but PRICEY.Wish calamari was as described in other reviews as flaky and soft but it was a standard calamari, nothing stood out unfortunately.The paella was good but lacking in lobster. There were more mussels than clams but both were tasty. Unfortunately the amount of shrimp was lacking for a $60 plate.The other 2 dishes were great with the bistec and chicken respectively.Our waitress was attentive and receptive to our requests, wish I knew her name to state it here.Overall, a good experience. Again the cost is a stinger but what can we as customers navigating for good food expect in 2026, the lights must be kept on.Please give this restaurant a chance, even the music took me back to a younger time in my life.Thank you for feeding me and my family.

2026-08-08T18:31:24.818Z

Food was delicious my server Derrick was amazing!!!! definitely will be back!!!!

2026-08-06T22:36:36.222Z

This was our first visit to Casa Mia since it was an Italian restaurant. Now it is a Latin cuisine establishment. They have very nice outdoor seating if you are looking for Al fresco dining. Interior was nice, simple and easily navigable. I ordered an Old Fashioned made with Bulleit bourbon. While it was acceptable, I think it was not made with simple syrup. An appetizer was the Crispie Calamari, and that it was. Batter was light and crispy and the calamari was cooked just right. Not like chewing rubber bands in some places. These were crispy and tender. Two entrees were Pernil de La Casa which is slow cooked pulled pork served with rice and beans maduros and a red garlic monitor sauce. The other entree was a Seafood Paella which is a medley of plump shrimp, tender muscles, succulent calimari.and lobster srved over saffron infused rice. Both dishes were excellently prepared and plated. We also ordered a side order of Maduros which ere cooked to perfection and as sweet as would be expected.So of you are traveling Rt 211 in Middletown, give some thought to stopping at the corner of 211 and Goshen Turnpike for some very tasty Latin cuisine. They also have live entertainment.

2026-08-02T19:06:42.960Z

Amazing brunch and drink specials. The DJ on Sunday is amazing. Shy is super friendly and upbeat. A place to go with friends for a good time.

2026-08-02T17:50:54.778Z

Everything was great! Shout out to Shy thank you for the great service

2026-07-30T22:31:29.399Z

Great place and time

2026-07-19T19:01:21.468Z

Great food, excellent and friendly service. Definitely recommend!