Thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and garlic bread! Might go back just for the garlic bread! The system malfunctioned while taking it order, so the kitchen prepared the wrong pizza, but the staff was kind enough to remake it for us! Less

Good pizza, lots of cheese, great crust. It’s not wood fired, Neapolitan style, definitely not thin crust. If that’s what you want, go somewhere else. This is hearty, thick pizza. Less

Came in for a happy hour deal of a beer & personal pizza for $15. Decent deal. Pizza was quite good. Got the Hawaiian and the pep + onion.The interior is dark and desolate - definitely in need of an update though. Also would suggest they use actual Maui pineapple rather than pineapple from a can. Told the server that and the response was that they go bad fast and are more expensive. Ok, fair. But fresh is always better. Less

We had a pepperoni pizza, a kailua pork+pineapple pizza, and some housemade ranch. Everything was fantastic, but the ranch was next level. Prices were reasonable for the outstanding quality. We will definitely be back. Less

The place and food was great the customer service wasn’t though they were upset we called ahead when we were trying to have it made so we could make our flight it worked out but the pizza is also way over priced but it tasted good! They don’t add a lot of toppings for what you pay Less

Wonderful atmosphere with great service! One of the most responsible priced restaurants we’ve been to in this island. The wings were very good and extra crispy! We got the Salt and Vinegar and loved them! The pizza is good! The menu says it’s thin crust, but it’s not. Decent amount of pork on our Kalua Pork Pizza. Would’ve liked about double just to get an adequate amount in each slice. Pineapple is from a can. Not bad but would LOVE to have some local Maui Gold triangles on the pizza. Less

As with various places in Maui, this place is on the pricey side. Excellent pizza and excellent service. We ended up just sharing two small pizzas among 5 of us and it was a nice afternoon snack. Less

This place was excellent! We had keno as our server and he was super helpful with suggestions and great service. Would recommend trying this place out. Great pizza and great vibes Less

Off to a rough start with my online order being late, however, the service while I was waiting was super good. Kino and the rest of the staff were great 👍 they were down a cook so I will give them the benefit of the doubt! Less

This place is wildly popular. Every table was filled. The rake out business was outrageous. The pizza is decent. Lots of string making cheese. The tomato sauce was good. Crust is not crisp, so it is definitely a knife and fork pizza. Less

Bought veggie pizza with no mushrooms but added pineapple. We loved it. Bit pricey for "to go" but pizza is well done with good quality and quanity vegetables & cheese. We definitely want to eat there again next time. Less

Love Pizza Madness! Best pizza on Maui, made to order! Great selection of toppings and the wait staff is always friendly! We go every chance we get... Never disappoints! Less

My family and I got home a bit late from the Road to Hana and we were starving. So I ordered pick up from Pizza Madness. The pizza was ready on time. My husband went in to get it. Everyone was polite and courteous. The pizza was amazing. So so good! My daughter, who is very picky, ate her whole pizza. She absolutely loved it. Highly recommend! Less

Been coming to Maui for over 15 years and pizza madness is a must, I make sure to go at least twice each trip. Staff is the best, pizza is amazing, and the family salad is an honourable mention, always fresh and very tasty! The environment is epic with cool artwork ! Less

I'm not one to post a review, but while visiting we had to stop by as it was referred by a resident. GREAT tasting pizza. Cheese was super meaty, crust was chewy, but not flacid. Super chill and relaxing seating. We kept it simple with cheese pizza and beer and it was the best meal out of the day. Less

Chicken Alfredo pasta is delicious!! The wings starters are good (buffalo). The pepperoni pizza 🍕 is great! Highly recommended 👌 and you get coupons for the whales 🐋 tour and the aquarium. Less

The garlic parm wings are the best I have ever had! Great, fast service. The portions are large for the price. Highly recommend to anyone who is traveling or locals. Less

Good little pizza spot that is affordable considering we are on Maui. I saw they had a ton of take outs and delivery while I was dining in. Our waiter got slammed and wasn’t an attentive to my table, but it was only my daughter and I, and we don’t require much. Ordered a small Cesar salad which was very tasty, fresh and a decent portion before I devoured a bunch of carbs. Ordered a child’s pizza with only sauce - they put a TON of sauce on it which is unusual and a good thing but my daughter didn’t want that much and we just removed it off her pizza. I ordered a build your own with pineapple, basil, hot honey and pepperoni. Took a while to get mine- but I placed the kid’s pizza first and that came out super quick! I personally would rather wait on my pizza than my child be hungry and being just antsy. Pizza and the dough was very tasty and we would definitely eat here again! I would have posted a photo of my pizza but I ate it all before I realized I should grabbed a picture. Oh they also gave my daughter some pictures to color and some crayons! Very thoughtful and kid friendly! Less

Kaitlin is such a sweet heart and always makes us feel taken care of, even when it's busy. Everything is amazing here, even the sandwiches. Don't forget to try the Kirk special. Less

Pizza is like a food group for me, so when I state this pizza was terrific I mean it from my cholesterol-laden, cheese-loving, crust-enjoying little heart. The wings were good too, and hey, salad. Less

Our absolute favorite neighborhood pizza place on the island. The pizza is fantastic and the service is always great!! If you’re looking for a local favorite, that is casual with great food, you should check this place out. We are here every week. We recommend the pizza, meatballs, and the homemade ranch dressing is great on everything! Less

We are from Buffalo, New York, so to order pizza and wings you would think we’re crazy. But there are as good as Buffalo and that says a lot coming from Buffalonians 👍 highly recommend this place Less

We ordered a large (12 slices) 1/2 cheese 1/2 Special pizza with wings for take-out. *sauce for wings comes on the side. Maybe they will toss if you ask. The person that took our order on the phone was pleasant and helpful. When my partner picked up the food he said the staff was friendly and he didn’t have to wait long (wait time for our food was accurate). I was a little apprehensive to eat here based on the mixed reviews but I’m glad we did. The food was good. Would order from here again. Less

Great atmosphere! Waiters are the friendliest peeps ya'll meet. Go down there and grab some ono grindz pizza. My ohana and I go there often and they never disappoint. They got clean bathrooms, TV to watch football, or even surf competitions. We love the surf shows. Big tables that could fit a big group. Most of all the AC is just the best. The fish on their ceiling my kids love to always look at. Thanks for being such good company for us pizza madness, look forward to more pizza 🥰 Less

We dined in. Lots of seating available. Everything was clean. Greeted soon as we walked in. Order placed quickly. Food came out just as quick! Excellent flavor, crisp bottom, even the crust was delicious! Lake was our server, another unnamed guy brought our food, both were nice. Wife says the bathroom was clean! We look forward to trying that Philly cheesesteak next! Plenty of parking also. We were there about 5pm. Less

Pizza Madness is our go-to family pizza restaurant in Kihei. Wings are excellent, kid friendly, great place to watch a game or get a beer. Staff is really nice! Less

The best pizza on Maui! My entire family has been eating only pizza madness pizza for a while now. We had to get pizza from elsewhere recently…and it didn’t compare. No where near close. My daughter is very picky. She will eat pizza madness food, but not very many other places. Highly recommend! Less

If there was a 3.5 stars, that’s what I would give. The pizza wasn’t incredible, but I appreciated that they had gluten free crust. We did both regular and gluten free, as well as mozzarella sticks. The regular was pretty thick crust. This feels like a place you’d go with your family after a sports game…laid back, family friendly, nothing fancy. Less

Pizza Madness has been our go-to for consistently fantastic pizza over the last nine years. I'm also a big fan of the huge antipasto salad, which is a meal by itself. A word of caution about gift cards, though. Our children on the East Coast bought us a $25 gift card from the Pizza Madness website, printed it, and mailed it to us. When I brought the printout to the restaurant, I was told the card had no value on it. There was no way I could prove the card hadn't already been used, so I was just out of luck. We won't be trying gift cards again. Less

2nd time here and service was great. This time enjoyed their Basil Me and Pogrita Cocktail. Had their truffle fries and Meat lover pizza. Great place to hang out and enjoy with friends and family. Less

Great place for "chicago style" pizza. Pizza was very good, crust was delicious. Service was prompt and servers friendly. Anyone from Chicago area will definitely appreciate! Less

Amazing pizza, amazing staff and a welcoming atmosphere! Our pizza had tons of cheese and pepperoni on it and just the though of how good the pizza tasted is making my mouth water....so glad there are leftovers for a midnight snack lol Less

Service was great. The atmosphere was nothing to write home about, but it was much more than expected for a kind of dive bar/pizza joint. My wife and I got a large cheese pizza that was fantastic, and I'm sure their specialty pizzas are incredible based off how good just the regular ol' cheese was. Overall, it was a great experience and I would recommend it to others! Cheers! Less

For my first night back on Maui, this was the perfect spot to get something to eat for dinner. Food was picture perfect but I didn't take any pics because it was consumed too quickly. Beer selection was appropriate and diverse for everyone's taste. Less

We ordered a veggie pizza and it tasted amazing. We also ordered a garlic bread and that was good too. The service was quick and the vibe was good. It’s mainly for pizza with a drink but we enjoyed our time there. One thing we liked the most was that the pizza had lot of veggies, not a lot of veggie pizzas have them so we liked that it had lots of veggies. A 10 slice was enough for 2 ppl but we thought it was a bit expensive for the size. Less

We walked here from our condo, nearly 2 miles. We were a bit disappointed to walk into a place that seemed to have no A/C. It was really dark and had an odd vibe. Cocktails were good and I like how they offer pitchers of soda. My Hawaiian pizza was good and my son loved their wings. The server seemed very annoyed when we asked for ranch but she was otherwise friendly. Less

We had a long day out exploring the island and felt like having a good pizza to close out the day. This place was a short drive from our resort so we decided to give a try. We were seated right away as it wasn't that busy when we went and ordered right away. We both liked our pizzas and what made it better was the incredibly friendly service that we received while there. The crust was done quite well and we enjoyed the toppings. It was a good experience and worth our money. Less