2026-03-16T22:42:27.140Z

8 month update: still the best card shop in the state. The hiccups there have been are due to understandable growing pains. I do appreciate how the owners are quite proactive in taking in feedback and actually applying it to the business. If i could change anything, it would be the event sign up system online not using Shopify like the rest of the website so you can't use store credit for events unlesss you go in-store(a slight problem when you live an hour and a half away)Original review: Fair and friendly with good pricing on everything. The buylist system is great for only having to bring down the cards on it and the website is very easy to use.

2026-03-14T12:45:34.152Z

Amazing packaging - they took time and effort to ensure everything traveled safely. Highly recommend!!!

2026-03-12T20:13:48.555Z

Brittany packed my order perfectly and it came with some cool stickers. A+ will order again

2026-03-06T05:03:41.784Z

I live out of state and we don’t have a good card shop. Unfortunately that means I’d been turning to Amazon for a lot of my MTG needs, and far too often opened and/or damaged product was the result… Not anymore! These guys are fantastic! Their prices are extremely competitive, staff is quick and friendly with help, and the packaging was probably the best I’ve ever seen. I wish I’d taken pictures but other reviews have great examples. Every piece was individually padded with bubble wrap, and not just some loose plastic they shoved in the box, but truly secured with easy removal thanks to a handy “open” sticker and perfectly used tape. Many Realms is the store all competitors should strive to be with professionalism bordering on perfection. I’ll never again be stuck shopping for Magic the Gathering on Amazon. If you haven’t tried Many Realms, you’re missing out.

2026-03-05T21:56:20.779Z

Great shop, had exactly what I wanted! Kevin Helped me out a ton, lovely all around experience

2026-03-04T23:43:15.889Z

Best packaging I have ever seen.

2026-03-01T03:54:53.313Z

This place is really awesome! They have a great selection of cards and board games, plus the prices are great too.Special shout out to Pria who was very friendly when I came in and took the time to find the card I was looking for in the back warehouse. She's the real MVP for getting me my commander for my MTG deck!!

2026-02-25T06:45:23.806Z

What an amazing shop! I wish I was local to these guys. Their mail ordering is simply fantastic. Everything is packed so securely and shipped quickly! If you’ve found this review and you’re on the fence, don’t be. These guys should be the benchmark that other card shops strive to be!